Heritage Day humbug – why do we erase the legacies that are really worth remembering?

People’s culture and South Africa’s heritage of struggle are far more worthy of celebration tomorrow than all the irrelevancies the public discourse invokes.

Nguni bull.jpg

So, tomorrow is Heritage Day – or, as the media insist on calling it, National Braai Day. For some of us, that latter is never going to stick. Maybe it’s the environmental impact of raising and then charring all that red meat: clearing land for grazing animals or the soy that feeds them, plus all that CO2 from charcoal and the 23-times-worse methane from cow farts (not putting you off your steak, am I?) are all really bad for the sustainability of our planet.

But I eat meat too, so maybe it’s something else.

Perhaps it’s the way something that should be priceless and in people’s hearts is instead turned into an excuse for self-aggrandizing politicians and grasping shopkeepers to sell us things: ‘heritage’ couture, braai tongs and promises.

Vlakplas.jpgPerhaps it’s the way the day is used to emphasise feudal difference, with the whole country turned into a gigantic, booze-soaked cultural village within whose walls legislators scurry to restore the worst of colonial-designed, patriarchal law via the Traditional Courts Bill.

And, inescapably, it’s the foul miasma from all those cosy braais at Vlakplas and Bird Island – not something any sane person should want in their heritage.

But before Ebenezer Scrooge takes over completely, let’s consider some of the things that are worth remembering. We can notice, while we’re at it, that most of them have been completely erased from the dominant public discourse about Heritage Day.

freedom-charterHow about, for example, our history of struggle? Not those convenient corners opportunistically appropriated by political parties when it suits them to win votes. Rather, the fact that millions of ordinary people risked and gave their lives every day across more than two and a half centuries to defeat colonialism and apartheid and put something better in their place. That something better is beautifully summed up in the Freedom Charter (http://www.historicalpapers.wits.ac.za/inventories/inv_pdfo/AD1137/AD1137-Ea6-1-001-jpeg.pdf ). Its goals have still not been achieved, and some of those who should have been fighting hardest for them have instead betrayed them. But none of that devalues them, and Heritage Day should be the time to celebrate the women and men who fought and are still fighting for their realisation.

And how about people’s culture? There are the obvious things: the jazz legacy, the intricate creative artistry of traditional attire and architecture, the social commentary of praise songs, the art, poetry and music by workers in town and country and liberation soldiers – and still, today, by this generation of activists around Marikana, Fees Must Fall, One in Nine and more.

But there are other cultural legacies too. Despite the patronising guff of the chattering classes on 702, there is, for example,  a township heritage of care and concern for the environment, expressed most powerfully in the mid-1980s by the Peoples Parks movement (https://asai.co.za/jdownloads/Peoples%20Culture/Imvaba/worksbycollectives.pdf ). Young people and their parents worked to take control of ugly, neglected township spaces. From junk, they built artworks, playground equipment and shelters in which to gather, using community spirit to transform their environment. Apartheid razed the people’s parks – and the market obsessions of the post-apartheid regime stole the confidence, solidarity and creativity that had built Unity Park, Crossroads People’s Park in Oukasie, Biko Park, Alexandra township’s Garden of Peace and more. That’s a legacy worth celebrating and reclaiming this Heritage Day.

lib proj onstage
The Liberation Project on stage

If you want some music for all this genuine heritage you won’t see on TV, you could do worse than pick up a copy of The Liberation Project (http://www.theliberationproject.co.za/) 3-CD set. More than 140 musicians from South Africa, Italy, Cuba and more worked together live and across the aether to create a compilation of familiar and unfamiliar liberation songs, fresh arrangements and new compositions celebrating people worldwide striving for freedom. The late Ray Chikapa Phiri was a guiding spirit until his death; other names you’ll know include Sipho ‘Hotstix’ Mabuse, Roger Lucey, Aus Tebza Sedumedi, Tony Cedras, Phil Manzanera, Cyril Neville, Juan de Marcos – it’s impossible to list them all. The CD-set and a DVD will launch formally at Joburg’s Melrose Arch on October 3, but tomorrow is the right date to start playing it. Happy Heritage Day.

Lib Proj




Bheki Mseleku: remembering a brilliant Earthling

A number of people asked me at yesterday’s Wits Bheki Mseleku event if I could publish what I said. So, here it is. Some parts of this first appeared in 2008 as an obituary in the excellent, sadly short-lived literary magazine Baobab. We heard wonderful reminiscences and reflections last night. I hope my fellow panellists – Lindelwa Dalamba, Salim Washington, Eugene Skeef, Nduduzo Makhathini and Afrika Mkhize – also publish theirs.

Bheki Mseleku

I’m not a player and can’t do the kind of analysis musicians like Salim Washington, Afrika Mkhize and Ndududo Makathini can. So I’m going to talk about the Bheki I knew.

Make no mistake, if geniuses exist, musically, Bheki Mseleku was one. This afternoon I was listening to Meditations, Bheki’s least well-known album: his solo recital at the 1992 Bath international Festival. The first track is a 32-minute improvisation; the second a 15-minute one. You need to hear it.

But I can’t help thinking he’d be amused by the title for tonight’s discussion – and find it just a little bit ridiculous.


Because when you talked to Bheki, the thing he constantly stressed was what we all have in common. “We’re all just Earthlings” was something he liked to remind us, especially when disagreements, or somebody’s ego, were getting in the way. And “Earthlings”, rather than “South Africans” or “Zulu-speakers” or even “musicians” was very deliberately chosen. Not only do we all share humanity on this planet – but we have to be mindful that there might be other entities waiting to jam with us out there among the spheres …Bheki was an Afro-futurist long before that term got fashionable.

Celeb.jpgI interviewed Bheki 3 or 4 times over his time in this country. But the time I got to know him best was in Gaborone, in Botswana, in 1985. On June 14, the Boers had raided the town, killing more than a dozen, smashing among others the MEDU cultural structure that had made the place so hospitable for defiant, original music. Bheki, Barney Rachabane and a number of other South Africa-based players had arrived to collaborate with MEDU and Batswana musicians (Tony Cedras, Motswana guitarist John Selolwane, more…) making an album with Hugh Masekela. But after the raid, night stopped being a time to relish the joyous, rebellious creativity of Gaborone’s players. It was a time of apprehension, when you woke up fearful every time a car slowed at your gate, or slept only to dream the faces and voices of the dead. For some, creativity took second place to staying safe or watching out for friends, and those musicians were basically marking time as Hugh set up, from outside, the next phase of a planned tour.

Night terrors

Like all of us, Bheki became a gypsy. It really wasn’t safe to stay in one place for too long. So he’d crash, and when he had a gig, he’d hijack a clean T-shirt from one comrade in the house; washing gear from another. If he had a jacket, he’d probably left it somewhere else last night. It didn’t worry him: “People are good; someone will bring it back, or another one will be given. Why are you so worried about things? Things are heavy; they weigh you down. What’s important is the lightness in the heart. Come on: it’s time to play.”

He wasn’t a saint. He was deeply spiritual, but he had no patience for narrow, censorious organised religion. I remember one evening when evangelists from some well-funded American faith organisation knocked on the door. The rest of us were all for sending them away – you never knew who such people really were. But not Bheki. “Wait,” he said. “ Watch. I’m going to fuck with their heads.” And he started such a high-level theological argument about spirit and freedom that by the end of it the evangelists’ heads were spinning and they didn’t know what planet they were on, while the rest of us were helpless with suppressed laughter. For Bheki, music and spirit were, in photographer Val Wilmer’s words, “serious as your life.” But there was an irreverent, witty side to him too, and we shouldn’t always remember him as wrapped in mystical solemnity.

Midnight healing

After a gig, Bheki would charm his way past the security guard into the Gaborone National Museum and Art Gallery: the only place in town with a good piano. Him, and a gaggle of other players – South Africans Batswana; the remnants of our two resident expatriate bands, Jonas Gwangwa’s Shakawe and Hugh’s Kalahari; guys from the Botswana Defence Force; occasionally a wannabe musical youngster from the University.

One hand on the keys, the other on his sax

And that’s where another facet of his genius showed. Not only did musically amazing things happen, but Bheki’s midnight symposiums at the Museum were part of the healing. It was hard to hold fear when you were caught up in a debate on whether there could be any such thing as a new combination of notes – or has everything been played before, somewhere in the Universe? Impossible to surrender to nightmares, listening to Bheki analyse Trane’s solo from A Love Supreme, put it back together as a duet with one hand on the keys and the other on his sax, and then slide off the piano stool so we could hear what Tony Cedras or the Motswana pianist and journalist the late Rampholo Molefhe would make of it. It was all part of sharing and spreading the light and everybody there – even me, who still can’t read a note – learned from it.

In Charles Dickens’ words, those were the best of times as well as the worst of times, with Bheki collaborating with others to create a free, light space in which to play. The music on Meditations reminds me of those Museum piano nights.


20 years on in South Africa, the Bheki I talked to was heavier, graver, sadder. “I wrote to X University,” he tells me sadly, “but they didn’t answer my letter. And Y University wants me to send them my qualifications before they’ll consider me.”

International respect

COVER042Which ones would those be, I wondered. The Mercury nomination for Celebration? The praise from critics worldwide? The covers in international magazines such as The Wire? Tributes paid by Marvin “Smitty” Smith, Pharoah Sanders, Abbey Lincoln, Charlie Haden, Kenny Barron? Trane’s mouthpiece, given to him by Alice Coltrane at Newport in 1977? (No, not that. When he was home at last from exile, it was stolen by robbers who probably flogged it for five rand.) Perhaps copies of the albums: Celebration; Meditations; Timelessness; Star Seeding; Beauty of Sunrise?

Family legacy

For Bheki was self-taught, with no degree certificate to brandish. Born in Lamontville, a suburb of Durban, in 1955, music was in his blood. His father and uncle were vaudevillians William and Wilfred Mseleku, leaders of the Amanzimtoti Royal Players, one of the most extensively recorded South African entertainment groups of the 1930s. Later, his father got religion. For a long time the family piano was kept locked. But his mother, Elvira, would give Bheki the keys when his father was away. Eventually, older brother Langa was allowed to practice, and he became Bheki’s mentor. Bheki persevered, despite a go-kart accident that robbed him of the top joints of two fingers (and the piano finally being chopped up for firewood). He mastered piano, sax and guitar and played with young bands in and around Lamontville, but he was soon scouted into the Johannesburg jazz scene. According to Cape Town pianist Roger Koza – who worked with Mseleku in ‘70s touring band The Cliffs – it was legendary Malawi-born bandleader/impressario Dick Khoza who first spotted his talent.

The young Bheki

70s soul

In Joburg he was schooled in two of the most interesting bands of the 70s: The Drive and Spirits Rejoice. The first, founded in 1971 by reedman Henry Sithole took a soulful, hard-bop approach to original tunes and Bheki puts in a neat organ solo on the group’s bump jive hit ‘Way Back Fifties’. The far more explicitly experimental Spirits Rejoice, founded by drummer Gilbert Matthews and sxaophonist Duke Makasi in 1974 gave him space to spread his improvising wings, and hooked him up with guitarist Russell Herman who, until Herman’s death, became his manager and refuge in 1980s London. Then a stint touring with Malombo showed him how you could be at home in music wherever you traveled.

Universal man

For Bheki, where you were, was irrelevant. He believed we’d all lived before and would all live again; that these lives could be on Earth or on other planes and planets. It was both faith and lived metaphor; it took him to Hindu temples, Buddhist retreats and Sufic meditation, and it allowed him to consciously opt out of a world where music was parcelled neatly into genre boxes and sold by the pound, and live his life differently: sharing the light.

“I’m not a jazz musician,” he told me and other critics. “I don’t know what that means. The industry invented that box.”

with good friends including Eugene Skeef (l)

But contemporary South Africa bruised him. The industry wanted to buy and sell, not share, and Bheki’s sprawling, glittering, different talent was not easily commodifiable: “not commercial enough”, they told him. Only one album, Home at Last – a gentle, lyrical collection – came out of his time here. When he was sad, he neglected himself: eating wrong or not at all; forgetting the insulin his diabetes demanded. That made him sick and blocked his creative spirit. And so, back to London, with a jazz scene more hospitable to exploratory sounds, and supportive friends such as Eugene Skeef. But years of self–neglect (sometimes he’d play for a couple of days without pausing to eat or drink) and the sadness, had irreparably damaged his health.

On to a higher plane

After his death, in September 2008,Bheki’s elder brother Langa talked to The Sowetan newspaper: “Bheki’s daughter has been trying to organise for him to play at home for five months. Nobody was interested. Now he is dead, everybody is interested.”

The best way to remember Bheki, I think, is to remember all of him. The earnest, committed spiritual seeker, and the mischievous deflater of pomposity. The soaring musical genius, and the man who could groove a keyboard vamp on Way Back ‘Fifties that insinuated its way under your soles and made you move. UK Guardian critic John Fordham said he could sound as though he was playing for a dance one moment and an act of worship the next, and sometimes both at once. And the absolutely best way to pay tribute to him is to do what he loved and longed to do. First: learn and teach (he had made himself impressively learned in both ideas and sounds). And second: breathe in the air of freedom and breathe out good music.

b@club 606 london.jpg
Playing at Club 606 in London

A voice is a voice because of other voices: Gabisile Motuba and the collectivity of sound

“What happens,” asks vocalist and composer Gabisile Motuba, “when the voice in a piece of music isn’t ‘the singer’?”

Tshwane University of Technology graduate Motuba is describing the genesis of her new album Tefiti, Goddess of Creation. In one sense, Tefiti is a second album, following the collaborative Sanctum Sanctorium ((https://itunes.apple.com/us/album/sanctum-sanctorium/1372986074) with Swiss pianist Malcolm Braff and percussionist (and partner) Tumi Mogorosi.


In another, however, it’s a completely new departure. “There were many sources of ideas for Sanctum,” she says. “Malcolm’s sense of musicality had a big impact, and we respected that [but] I’ve since spent nearly three years thinking about sound and the idea of voice and trying to ask what exactly they are.”

Motuba has composed all 10 tracks for this outing, working with a string quartet comprising violinists Kabelo Motlhomi and Lebogang Ledwaba, viola-player Simiso Radebe and cellist Daliwonga Tsangela, as well as bassist Thembikosi Mavimbela. Mogorosi plays drums and timpani on two tracks.

In contrast to a conventional ‘singer’s album’, Motuba’s voice isn’t continually foregrounded – “rather it’s just another frequency.” It’s a mistake, she says, to assume that the inspiration for the use of strings is classical music. “No, it doesn’t pull from that.

“The strings help to create a collective sound. I’ve never worked with them before, but they’re a way of articulating community through four-part harmony. It’s a lot like church choral singing” (Motuba grew up with the choral sounds of the Methodist Church) – “It comes together as one beautiful sound but everybody’s brought something different and personal into that. ”

Ideas of community as a social force – “being a person, but being rooted in the collective” – are strong in Motuba’s music, not merely as thematic inspiration, but as tools for her creative process. “Music isn’t just inspired by other music. It’s a response, shaped by who you are and who you speak to. I think we’re in a time that’s seeing the death of individualism and the rise of the collective, and that’s connected to how you group sounds together when you compose.”

I’m reminded of the late Mankunku Ngozi also telling me that music wasn’t just music, but “how you walk; how you greet.” Those politics are present in the themes of the tracks too: Wretched is inspired by Fanon; there’s poetry from MoAfrika Mokgathi, and an intense exploration of The Disruption of the Black Child. On the deeply personal Remember Me, inspired by the death of a close friend, “I was paying homage to her and to the history that’s happening now: friendship, community and the communal struggle for survival. The music is an echo of what’s happening now.” For Motuba, becoming a mother underlined the irrelevance of individualism: “After that, it’s never just about you.”

So Motuba isn’t much impressed by the current emphasis on musical performance as what she calls “the embarrassment of being a spectacle…Branding and becoming a product… There’s nothing for us there.” She tells of a popular Sunday newspaper that was prepared to cover the album “But ‘we don’t want to talk about the music – let’s talk about you instead’! Listen, I have important things to say without being turned into a commodity.”

Commodification isn’t the only barrier a female composer faces. Motuba previously led a group called The Trip, features in Mogorosi’s Project ELO, and currently has more work in progress with Wretched, exploring dissonance. “I landed into composing because of what I was interested in, and how I have always put songs together. The process makes me comfortable with sound and lets me move away from ‘jazz vocalist’ to be somebody who’s interrogating jazz, sound, community and identity.” She cites Asian-American improviser Jenn Shyu, trombonist Siya Makuzeni and jazz scholar Dr Lindelwa Dalamba as influences on that journey: “In different ways, they’re all speaking to those ideas.”

But from the Joburg male classical establishment she has sometimes encountered polite disinterest bordering on disbelief that a young, black, female, jazz-backgrounded composer actually exists. “That’s four strikes against me, I guess,” she says wryly. “It seems as if people look on feminism in our field as just making space for music played by women, and it stops there. Nobody’s thinking about a feminist process or content, or in how the music is presented. Those are the places we can push back against the psychic violence of ‘You really don’t count’.”gabi

“That’s why I think Gretchen Parlato’s important as a feminist musician. She’s a strong jazz musician and you can hear her taking the decisions in the music: on articulation, phrasing, sound – those all affect the things we’re trying to say. Or when you hear an accompanist like [male pianist] Gerald Clayton. The consideration you can hear him giving to the singer and the other instrumentalists, that’s also a feminist way of working.”

Tefiti isn’t a predictably sweet album of voice and strings. There’s slow, quiet beauty and delicacy, but it lives alongside righteous anger, sadness and relentless pulses in the narratives that unfold. Rather than classical ornamentation, the strings often create that most African of musical patterns: groove. And the voice – make no mistake, it’s a beautiful voice – surges and recedes like the tide, moving through the spaces created by strings and rhythm: sometimes in the lead, often one strand in an intriguing sonic weave. Like they say, Motho ke motho…

RESPECT: Hamba Kahle Aretha Franklin


I was away last week, and so didn’t post immediately on the much-mourned death of musician and social activist Aretha Franklin. Here, you can find a full and detailed biography.https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/aretha-franklin-is-as-immortal-as-can-be

Here is something rather more pointed and personal: novelist Candace Allen’s memory of the impact of Aretha on her life. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/aug/17/aretha-franklin-voice-black-girls-queen-of-soul

Allen, incidentally , is the author of one of the best fictional portraits of a female jazz artist: Valaida. (https://www.amazon.com/Valaida-Candace-Allen/dp/1844081729 )

And here the Washington Post interrogates Trump’s claim in his “tribute” that the artist “worked for me”.https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2018/08/17/aretha-franklin-worked-for-me-claims-trump-did-she/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.1e84c343740c

Even without the fact-checks, it’s clear that without any reflection at all, Trump reverted to a classic racist trope without a moment’s pause. Unsurprising. But Aretha did not need his words anyway. She had – and has – our hearts.

Virtuosi, revolutionaries and pirates: a playlist for Women’s Day

Two Women’s Day greetings popped on What’sApp this morning. One was an extremely pink bowl of roses. The other, fringed by itty-bitty SA flags, showed a woman in traditional attire carrying an extremely heavy pot on her head. We’re flowers – or we do all the household work. Here’s a playlist for Women’s Day and the week that follows: music by and in one case for women that gives the finger to the stereotypes.


1) As homage to the roots, here are Lungiswa Plaatjies and Madosini with Solal’emaweni: referencing some of the most complex and inventive of South African traditional music – music from the women’s domain: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ReSlehqTJA

2) Building from those roots, nobody should need an introduction to Thandiswa Mazwai’s Nizalwa Ngobeni. The song will remain a classic for as long as we continue to forget our heroes (male and female) and their ethics and vision. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZ1D-ndTxpE

3) Throughout the centuries, women have fought for their own rights and those of their communities. In the early years of the Twentieth Century, this American song for the rights of women workers, Bread and Roses, drew on the ideas of German Marxist revolutionary Rosa Luxembourg. It’s sung here by Joan Baez. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LWkVcaAGCi0

Striking women textile workers: USA, 1912

4) Dolores Ibarruri -– ‘La Pasionaria’  – was a hero of the Spanish Civil War. This Spanish workers’ song was written for her. It’s played here by bassist Charlie Haden and guitarist Antonio Forcione. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A2MR7nUBRGA

5) South Africa, too, had – and still has – its struggles against racism and fascism. Nants’Indoda was written by trade unionist Vuyisile Mini and sung as he was led to the gallows. For Mama Africa, Miriam Makeba, singing it was one of the ways she alerted the world to the struggles and suffering of the South African majority. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DYwgmOxhUvk

6) A very young Dorothy Masuku was chased out of South Africa for questioning the laws of Dr Malan and asking in song who killed Patrice Lumumba. Then the Rhodesian Secret Service pursued her too, for writing songs like this, Bazukahttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bU7l2_KSxOc

7) Billie Holiday’s Strange Fruit was one of the earliest Black Lives Matter song. Scholar Dr Angela Davis says it “put the elements of protest and resistance back at the center of contemporary black musical culture.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dnlTHvJBeP0

Clare Loveday

8) Then there are the struggles within music. Virtuoso playing and composition are so often stereotyped as the realm of men that we are not permitted to see the large numbers of women already achieving in these fields. Clare Loveday is a South African composer who has won multiple international commissions and collaborated with artists including Nandipha Mntambo. Here’s her work Shadow Lines, performed at the 2016 SAMRO Awards finals by winner Dylan Thabisher https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KYOwmtPsSFg 

9) Here’s a concert of original, virtuoso solo flute from Nicole Mitchell in New York: astounding playing in terms of both vision and instrumental mastery https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n5CXlPeeVn4

10) Finally, for anybody who’s ever worked in the service industries (I have occasionally been a waitress), Nina Simone sings Pirate Jenny. The song is from the Threepenny Opera by Berthold Brecht and Elizabeth Hauptmann, with music by Kurt Weill. Based on John Gay’s 18th century play, it became a satire on the fundamental immorality of capitalism in a 1930s Germany careering towards Hitlerism. Jenny appears to be a servant, but she has a far more satisfying career as a pirate. And Simone takes the song deep into the racist American South, giving it extra, chilling, resonance. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V7awW5nrDHk